| Method | Primary Mechanism | Duration | Key Advantage | Key Counseling Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Norethindrone minipill 0.35 mg | Cervical mucus thickening | Daily (3-hr window) | No estrogen | 3-hour dosing window — strictest of all methods |
| Desogestrel minipill 75 mcg | Ovulation suppression + mucus | Daily (12-hr window) | Ovulation suppression without estrogen | More forgiving missed-pill window than norethindrone |
| Etonogestrel implant (Nexplanon) | Ovulation suppression | 3 years | Most effective reversible contraceptive | Irregular bleeding common (year 1); fertility returns in 3–4 weeks |
| Depot medroxyprogesterone acetate | Ovulation suppression | 12 weeks per injection | Large depot buffer vs. drug interactions | Fertility delay: average 9–10 months after last injection |
| Levonorgestrel intrauterine device (52 mg) | Local endometrial + mucus | 5–8 years | Minimal systemic progestin; preferred with enzyme-inducing drugs | Not affected by systemic drug interactions |
| Condition | Combined Hormonal | Progestin-Only | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prior VTE or thrombophilia | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Category 2 (safe) | Ethinyl estradiol amplifies clotting risk |
| Migraine with aura | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Category 2 (safe) | Ethinyl estradiol multiplies stroke risk |
| Severe hypertension | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Category 2–3 | Controlled hypertension: Category 3 for combined |
| Age over 35, heavy smoking | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Category 2 (safe) | Arterial thrombotic risk synergy |
| Active liver disease | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Category 3 | Ethinyl estradiol stimulates compromised liver |
| Current breast cancer | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Category 4 (absolute CI) | Exception: ALL hormonal methods contraindicated |
Most conditions that make combined hormonal methods Category 3 or 4 are Category 1 or 2 for progestin-only methods — because the risk arises from ethinyl estradiol, not from progestin. The single exception: current breast cancer is Category 4 for ALL hormonal methods.